videos to watch:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NnAhE6IADts
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LVyOmjWeYP0
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Uc_3SYInn9g
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L05TYBXwU3A
Tuesday, 4 August 2015
essay so far (low editing):
How conclusive is the
evidence supporting the theory that Marilyn Monroe’s death was due to suicide?
“SIXTIES sex symbol Marilyn Monroe was at the height
of her fame when she died from an overdose of sleeping pills at the age of 36
and news of her passing shocked the world”[1]
On the fifth of August 1962, film star
Marilyn Monroe, “was found lying naked in her bed with an
empty bottle of Nembutal sleeping pills by her side”[2]
and, “after a brief
investigation, Los Angeles police concluded that her death was caused by a
self-administered overdose of sedative drugs and that the mode of death is
probable suicide.”[3] Theories vary on Marilyn’s
death ranging from her commonly accepted suicide, to more unpleasant suspicions
that Marilyn was brutally murdered, as the evidence to support the official
reports has gaping holes which have captivated millions for over forty years. As
evidence available is shockingly limited, historians must be critical as to
whether sources show bias or are presenting information that is best suited to
their own personal desires. John Miner, witness of the autopsy, has spoken out
on his belief that Marilyn was murdered, Unsolved History explores many
theories and provides supportive points that Marilyn’s death was as reported. The
theories and evidence of one documentary contradicts that of another, and
comparisons are commonly made in order to establish which source is potentially
more reliable that the others.
John Miner, “a former prosecutor in Los Angeles”[4]
was present during the investigations surrounding Monroe’s death and publicly
concluded that he believed Marilyn Monroe had been murdered. The Sydney Morning
Herald reported in March of 2011 an article conveying Miner’s thoughts
following his death at age 92, where it was documented he had suggested
Marilyn’s body was found at
approximately three am, however the police were not notified until at least
four twenty am[5],
over an hour after the body had been discovered.
It was known by those living
at her residence that Marilyn commonly slept with the door unlocked, but
closed. On the night of her death there are many claims[6]
that state her door was locked, a variation in normal behaviour that could
suggest her death was a result of suicide. Robert Litman, psychiatrist and
member of the ‘suicide team’ of the case stated that the locking of the door
could, “suggest intention to die”[7].
Litman continues to state that in previous suicide attempts Marilyn had, “let
people know what she was doing”[8],
acknowledging that the official report stated probable suicide which created a
problem as it was not conclusive. The UNsolved History documentary[9]
reconstructs the scene at which Marilyn died, and tested the effects of the
Nembutal tablets she consumed in a lab to decipher whether a potential accidental
overdose was possible. The results found suggest that Marilyn would have been
unconscious before consuming the remaining 12 pills that would be needed in
order to affect her in a lethal manner.
The researches at Unsolved
History suggest that the most probable cause of death was an intentional
overdose, with Marilyn consuming 24-25 Nembutal pills simultaneously.
However, John Miner still
strongly believes that the discolouration of Marilyn’s colon suggests that she
did not consume the Nembutal herself, rather was administered it. Twenty years
after the original investigation, Miner theorised that Marilyn’s discoloured
colon and lack of intestinal content within her lower colon implies the poison
was administered through an enema. For this theory to be conclusive, Marilyn
must have been compliant with those running the procedure, suggesting she was
already heavily sedated. Marilyn’s lack of consciousness would match the levels
of Chloral Hydrate found in her system.
However, this is inconclusive as the door may
have been locked from the inside, and the room evacuated, if foul play was
involved.
Marilyn’s death was confirmed
probable suicide in 1962
, however many elements of
reports do not match up, and as a result many theories have been speculated
surrounding the truth around the 36 year olds passing.
US attorney general: Robert f
kennedy
3 known previous suicide
attempts, each time she had been rescued by calling for help.
Last known person whom she
corresponded with was peter lawford, who stated, “her voice was slurred, and
trailed off”[10].
This call was estimated to have been around the time of 9pm, if these
statements are true lawford may have been the last person Marilyn contacted
before her time of death.
89 degree body temperature at
the time of the autopsy suggests her death occurred at some time between 10pm
and 2am, meaning she must have consumed the pills at some time between 8pm and
1am
Marilyns normal night time
medicine was Librium not Nembutal
She had plenty of Librium on the
night of her death, with many half filled bottles accessible within her home
Questions motivation to go
out and get a prescription for these new drugs when she had plenty at home
Its is known that her mother,
and two of her grand parents had suffered from depression also and therefore it
would be more likely for her to have inherited the mental illness potentially
resulting in suicidal tendencies.
Murder by injection is not considered a
viable option, as she had no visible needle marks on her skin.
day of her death articles covered every
newspaper
theory one: suicide
-
Widely
accepted
-
Evaluate
evidence and sources
Theory two: CIA/US government
Theory three: Mafia
The suicide:
Facts, analysis, opinion
The murder:
Methods, analysis
The motive:
Theories, analysis
[2] On This Day BBC, http://news.bbc.co.uk/onthisday/hi/dates/stories/august/5/newsid_2657000/2657289.stm,
(accessed 2/7/15)
[7] 35:06 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZfH7SzDiSiY
(3 aug)
[8] ibid 35:35 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZfH7SzDiSiY
(3 aug)
[10] ibid 43:00
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)